Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
It isn't easy to explain why you love Severus Snape to other fans, let alone to the so-called 'normal' people you have to meet every day. To anyone who thinks the books are just for children, you run the risk of seeming emotionally immature, if not definitively insane. But there are lots of good reasons, if people would only open their minds, why Severus Snape obsession is a very understandable, and even logical, phenomenon.   

This essay (mostly new work, but with some excerpts from my DA journal articles as well) is about why he appeals to me, and why he pretty much sums up every good experience I've had with reading in one glorious hook-nosed, greasy-haired package!

First of all, he is everything you admire about text-book villains, but without the unfortunate handicap of being mad or (particularly) murderous. He allows you to be sarcastic, despise the good guys, and still be right. He has all the stylish appeal of the bad guys – the good lines, snappy put-downs, sweeping black robes – and yet he gets to take the moral high-ground. He's allowed to feel exasperated with the conventional – and frankly idiotic – behaviour of the hero, while still helping him along.

It's like watching a big, cheesy action movie with a friend. Throughout the film, he's saying things like: "Oh, that is totally unbelievable. A normal person just wouldn't do that! This guy's an idiot." And, yet, when the credits roll, and your armchair critic sits back with a look of disgusted satisfaction on his face, you realize he was actually the director.

And that's the way it feels when you're a Snape-fan reading the Harry Potter books – as though you have a voice of reason beside you, pointing out the flaws of the other characters in a deadpan and entertaining way. For anyone who finds it hard to empathize with Harry's thoughtlessness – for anyone who clutches their forehead in exasperation when Harry says something that is bound to land him in detention again – for anyone who thinks that he's more concerned with defiant repetition than trying to get anyone to actually see his point of view – there is Snape.

There's a certain type of reader who needs that reassuring cynicism – for whom the good guys have always seemed a little bit simplistic and unreasonable. But, knowing what's right, you've never really had much luck sympathizing with the bad guys either. For you, there is Severus Snape.

His witty, appealing voice of dissent is one of the reasons the Harry Potter books are sophisticated enough to enthrall adults, as well as children. I have a theory that nobody who discovered the Harry Potter books when they were children falls in love with Severus Snape. I may be wrong, and I'm happy to be told that I am, but I think you have to discover the books after the age of fifteen or so in order to see the beauty in Severus Snape. It's not that children are simpler; it's just that they don't have the same tendency to appreciate voices of dissent. Two people can't be right at the same time to a child.

But, the older you get, or the more familiar you get with a story, the more the peripheral characters start to interest you. Every time I pick up Wuthering Heights, my sympathies lie with a different character (even once with Lockwood, but I think I might have been ill that day). Every time I pick up one of the Twilight books, my sympathies lie chiefly with myself.  

Severus Snape gets to have all of the fun of cynicism, without any of its laziness. Most cynics get told: "It's all very well for you to scoff. But what are you doing to save the world?" But Severus Snape has earned the right to scoff – he's funding Potter's idiocy with his own life, and nobody knows it until the very end.  

He reminds me of the vice character in medieval morality plays – a character who gets to step outside the action of the play and make comments to the audience about the plot. He seems like an outlet for J.K. Rowling's cynicism: the part of her which thinks: Oh, God, Harry – why can't you hold your tongue? Why can't you think before you speak? Aren't you just a little bit intoxicated by all this attention?'

Through this character, J.K. Rowling gets to criticize her hero. Lots of characters criticize her hero, of course – but Snape is the only one who can't be written-off at the end. Everyone else who slings mud at Harry is very firmly established in the 'bad-guy' camp; they're either snobs, psychopaths, or scandal-hungry reporters. But, when Snape is vindicated at the end and described by Harry as 'probably' (you have no idea how much that 'probably' irks me!) the bravest man he's ever met, his criticisms of Harry linger on in the memory - which is just the way he would have wanted it!    

Looking at Snape's persistent popularity, you start to wonder whether someone who steps outside the story so often can actually die in it. He refuses to be charmed by the hero; he refuses to root for the good guys, even while he's supporting them; he refuses to get swept up in the action until he can't help it. As an outsider in the narrative, his death is all the more shocking – but it is also all the more difficult to accept. Our imaginations seem to have rejected the idea. Even after all the drama of the Deathly Hallows, you would be forgiven for expecting the Potions master to be back to business as usual at the end of the novels – terrifying new students, sneering at Gryffindors and seething whenever someone mentions the word Potter.   

If he refuses to die in our imaginations, maybe it's because he refused to go along with the story in so many other ways. He resisted the current so well, right up until the end.   

The stolid refusal to get swept up in the story is one of my favourite things about Severus Snape. And, as a consequence, you get one of my other favourite things about him: his supreme emotional discipline.     

But Snape's discipline isn't absolute. If it was absolute, he would be a difficult character to empathize with: a kind of Edward Cullen, without the physical attractiveness. But his self-control wavers. It doesn't just waver – it crumbles. It comes crashing down with anger and grief and passion so intense that he seems almost mad – that his eyes bulge and he spits at people. That's what makes Snape's emotional discipline so thrilling – because I know that there's something underneath it – that there's everything underneath it.

J.K. Rowling describes him in every way as the bad guy: there's something bestial, something dark and sinister even about his love. The way he looks at Lily is 'greedy', his grief is like the sound of 'a wounded animal'. It's very reminiscent of Heathcliff saying that Cathy is his soul. But when Heathcliff's soul dies, he tears stuff up and hurts everybody. When Severus' soul dies, he takes a deep breath, pushes it all down under a sneering, icy façade, and thinks: what would my soul want me to do with the time I've got left to me?

And what did he hope to gain by it? Did he hope to see her again someday in heaven? I don't think so. Someone who'd lived the life of a Death Eater – someone who'd seen the things he'd seen, and done the things he'd done – would never presume on that. Did he do it because it was the right thing to do? Probably not. He wouldn't have been so angry that Harry had to die to defeat Voldemort, if all he wanted was the downfall of evil.

For me, he simply did it because he loved Lily, and he wanted to make her happy. If there was even a small possibility that she still existed in some form, somewhere, he would do anything – give up everything else he ever cared about – to make her happy. Improbable, obsessive and masochistic as that seems, you've got to give him credit for it.

And it comes from nowhere, this life-altering love. Nothing he's ever seen – certainly nothing he's ever experienced – could teach him how to love someone like that. It reminds me of these experiments they did in the nineteenth century to see which was the perfect language. Scientists took young children and brought them up with no access to language whatsoever – they were never spoken to. They were completely cut off from anyone who spoke a language at all. The justification for this was to see which language came naturally to humankind. Some people thought it would be Hebrew, or Aramaic – the languages of the Bible. Of course, what happened was that the children made up their own language, with its own rules – utterly unintelligible to anyone else – but just as rich and complicated as any language they could have learned from adults.

That's what Severus Snape seems like to me. A child starved of love, who nevertheless made up his own version of it, with its own rules. Of course it would look odd to us – we know what love is supposed to look like; we've been raised on it. He had no idea what it was; he just knew that he wanted it.

It was very single-minded, sublimely self-controlled, unhealthy but beautiful love. It wasn't what every girl wanted – it wasn't even what the heroine wanted – but it was astonishing. It made me believe in the resilience of the human spirit far more than Harry's ability to love despite his mistreatment by the Dursleys. Snape may have allowed unkindness to sour his attitude, but it had no power to sour his passion. It got stronger through being starved. It was utterly oblivious to the facts. It refused to be reasonable. But it had a logic so refined that every comparison between Snape and a beast simply crumbles:

I love this woman and I always will. It doesn't matter that she's a mudblood, or married, or no longer breathing. She's my priority. Whatever the world does, I am not changing.

My aunt's objection to Severus Snape – and one that I hear a lot – is, 'if he was in love with Lily, why was he so cruel to her son?' And I suppose that's a logical point of view, if human emotions were ever logical.

If you were love with Lily, but you bitterly despised James, it would be tempting to see their child as Potter's spawn. Like Simone de Beauvoir, you would probably see the baby as an invading alien in your loved one's body, sucking away all her life and individuality. She dies a mother's death, trying to shield her son from Voldemort. Motherhood usurps her whole identity.  And it's nothing extraordinary. When Harry is wondering whether Neville's mother would have given her life to save baby Neville, he thinks 'surely she would' –as if what Lily did wasn't brave but merely natural.  

In the Half-Blood Prince, when Harry is listening to the tragic life-story of Merope Gaunt, he says 'she had a choice – not like my mother'. And Dumbledore has to correct him. Of course she had a choice. You don't stop being a human being just because you're a mother. You don't stop fearing death just because you're a mother. Perhaps Severus is annoyed that Lily's bravery, as well as his own, is so often overlooked.  

It's easy to understand one of Lily's former friends resenting the child she died for. It would be easy enough to see Snape's point of view, even if the child didn't look uncanny like his father, and even if that father hadn't dangled him upside down and displayed his underwear in front of a laughing crowd of teenagers.

But that isn't all. I wouldn't like you to think I was arguing that Severus Snape is a victim. Even if he wanted to be nice to Harry, I don't think he would be able to. Being nice doesn't come naturally to him.       

Throughout the entire series, he's exerting every fibre of his being just to keep himself from strangling Harry Potter. Nobody would say, after reading the books, that he was trying to be nice to Harry. But they don't understand where he started from. They don't appreciate the current he had to swim against. All that cruelty is actually the end result of a lifelong campaign not to be a bastard. The effort doesn't match the results, but I still find it stunning.

And then, finally, there is the very endearing fact that all his bravest deeds are only appreciated after his death. His heroism is subtle and beneath the surface. And anyone who knows what it feels like to be misunderstood, overlooked or under-appreciated can instantly sympathize with that.  He is an outsider who still gets to participate – however indirectly – in the happy ending.

On a personal level, writing fanfiction on DeviantArt is a lot like being Severus Snape. Just as he is surrounded by people who present a more striking and obvious appearance of heroism, a writer on a website devoted to the visual arts is surrounded by many more striking displays of creativity. There are so many glorious watercolours, sketches, digital paintings and photomanips paying tribute to Severus Snape here – things that can immediately affect you and inspire you. But you have to set aside at least half an hour to read a chapter of fanfiction. There is a question-mark (and a perfectly valid one, I might add) over whether a writer should be here at all.  

It takes a lot of patience, imagination and sympathy to see the good in fan-fiction, just as it takes a lot of patience, imagination and sympathy to see the good in Severus Snape. But – and here's the heartening thing – people do it. So many people have the patience to unearth the good in things, even - as in the case of Severus Snape - when it does its best to remain hidden! We're not all Harry Potters – and thank heavens!
An essay to commemorate Severus Snape's birthday, and to celebrate the launch of our new group :iconspinners--end:

Some of it has been taken from old journal articles; lots of it is rushed; all of it is breathless with school-girl admiration for the Potions Master! ;)
Add a Comment:
 
:iconprettyflour:
prettyflour Featured By Owner Jan 14, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
This has been featured in my journal!

[link]
Reply
:iconmelitot:
Melitot Featured By Owner Apr 18, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
So many thumbs-ups! Loved it from start to finish =D
And I think that yes, fanfiction is a fundamental part of fandoms; if done well, it's more enriching than "simple" art not to mention the fact that one can fool themselves thinking some parts of Deathly Hallows never existed. I'm still so bitter about Severus' death. Who says that - ended the war and everything - he couldn't have found some measure of happiness? :(
Off to the rest of your magnificent gallery ;)
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Apr 18, 2012
Thank you! :hug: I'm really glad to hear you liked this! Yes, I still feel that Severus's fate was harsh, but, in a painful way, kind of magnificent (I loved that he died undiscovered, for example - I think that's how a Slytherin would have wanted to go - fooling everyone to the very end!) But yes, it still makes me so sad to think about it! :(
Reply
:iconmelitot:
Melitot Featured By Owner Apr 19, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Shouldn't have gone like that :no: :tears:
Rowling does have a pretty bleak vision of the world, I agree with you - and, judging from the blurbs about her new book, her future works are going to be even more depressing :(
Reply
:icongryffgirl:
Gryffgirl Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2012
Fabulous essay! You've named all of the reasons why Snape is the most interesting character in the series. I often find it hard to articulate why I like him so much and feel frustrated when I have to explain that it is possible to like both him and his nemeses as characters (I think that I'm one of the few fans who also loves the Marauders). The good guy characters would be so boring if you didn't have his acidic wit to counterbalance them! BTW, Jules Deranges tipped me off to your fiction. It is excellent. I have avoided most HP fanfics because they were unreadable, but you truly know the mind of this dark, fascinating character! :blackrose:
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Apr 8, 2012
:hug: Thank you so much! I'm really happy to hear you enjoyed this (and the fanfics too! They're so much fun to write, because there was never enough of Snape's dark sarcasm for me in the HP books - with a fanfic of my own, I can totally overdose on it! ;))

And Jules is an angel for recommending my writing! :hug:s to both of you, and thanks again for commenting,

Lucy xxxx



Reply
:iconluzff:
Luzff Featured By Owner Dec 9, 2011
God, I absolutely loved your essay! It's perfect, exactly the way I think! But one thing I want to add that you didn't give the attention I think it deserves, is the way he was bullied. Almost everyone who was bullied can sympathize with him, can understand that hatred, anger and bitterness. Sometimes I come to the conclusion, that even with loving parents like mine, if I just had the influence of some wanna-be Death Eaters, I could see myself getting in a situation very much like his (as possible in real life). And he didn't even have that! I think J.K. should have given more attention to his story, and explained a bit better how much abuse he actually suffered, because I've read a lot of fanfiction that makes it seem as if it didn't have much effect on him, and others where it was terrible and actually shaped his adult (and adolescent) self.
Well, now that I've written so much about him, I just want to congratulate you again and thank you for this wonderful essay of yours!
Hugs,
Luiza
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Dec 11, 2011
Thank you so much! :hug: I'm really glad you liked this essay (and sorry for the late reply - I've had a hellishly busy weekend, with house guests and Christmas shopping! :faint:)

Yes, you're right, anyone who has been bullied can instantly sympathize with Severus. It's funny, because Harry was technically bullied too, but I don't feel the same kind of empathy for him. Maybe it's because Harry didn't care as much what other people thought of him - or maybe because he always had Ron and/or Hermione sticking with him, so he was never totally alone. But yes, even with loving parents (which poor Sev probably didn't have) I think I could have turned into something like a Death Eater after I was bullied (as it is, it definitely turned me into a cynical pessimist like Severus! ;))

What's weird, too, is that Severus as an adult really does bully his students (not so much Harry, who can usually stand up for himself, but poor Neville!) and yet I still sympathize with him, because I understand how easy it is for people who've been bullied to take all that cruelty out on other people. (I think that's the sign of a very good character - when even their cruelty is kind of understandable!)

Anyway, thanks very much for your feedback on this essay - I really appreciate it! :hug: I often think I should update this and 'Tragic Consolations' based on the feedback I've received, because people have raised so many interesting points that I didn't originally consider. Maybe after Christmas I'll have some free time to do that... :fingerscrossed:
Reply
:iconluzff:
Luzff Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2011
I'm glad to know that my feedback raised any good ideas! You're welcome, I think the least you deserve after writing such wonderful and well thought out essays!
I am a cynical pessimist too, and even though Severus kind of bullies Neville, Harry, Hermione, etc, I still can sympathize with him because 1st: it's the only accessible outlet for his pain and anger and 2nd: even though I really like Hermione and Neville, I find most of Severus's "observations" and general criticisms are truthful and I think that if the other characters payed the deserved attention to Severus, they would grow out of their most aggravating flaws, like Harry's terrible impulsiveness, Hermione's annoying need to show that she knows everything (she should be like Severus: knows everything but just speaks out when necessary and expresses oneself in one's own words rather than just sprouting out textbook explanations) and Neville's insecurities and nervousness that block out his true potential.
God, I just can't shut up! :P
Well, if you're really going to update your essays it would be really nice, because it would probably better represent the opinion of most of Severus's fans :D
I can guarantee you that I'll read the updated versions and I'm also going to read Sympathetic Magic too, even though I would like to know just if he'll end up happy (with the girl) even if she isn't Lily, because I can't take more fics that end just like the books: with Severus alone and unhappy. Because one of the few reasons I read Severus fics is because I can't bear him ending up unhappy, life is already unfair enough as it is *-*
Thank you for everything and have a good Christmas and happy New Year,
Luiza
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2011
Thank you! :hug: Hope you have a great Christmas and a happy New Year too! No, Sympathetic Magic isn't canon (it did start off canon, but then the characters went through too many different experiences for them to quite be the same people they are in the canon story!) In fact, it's quite fluffy and romantic (although, if you want to avoid Sev heart-break - which I'm told he gets a lot of in the first half of 'Sympathetic Magic' - you could start reading at 'Spinning Plates' [link] which begins their seventh year at Hogwarts, where Severus and Lily are dating, and pretty much all over each other! ;))
Reply
:iconspirit-of-the-rain:
Spirit-of-the-Rain Featured By Owner Jul 15, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
This essay made me reevaluate exactly why I love Snape as a character, and if I am to be honest with myself, I never really knew. So I thank you for putting all of the reasons into one place, so my brain can sort them all out xD

One thing though, when you talk about the children creating their own language in the nineteenth century, I was wondering where I could read about that, it interests me 8D
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Jul 16, 2011
Thank you so much! :hug: I'm really happy to hear that you liked this! (And I love the quote at the foot of your comments box - I feel exactly that way about Saturdays: big temporal tipping-points where anything is possible. Could you let me know where the quote's from? I'd love to read/see it!)

I read about language experiments on children in Stephen Fry's blog here: [link]

He's amazing, I thoroughly recommend that essay - but, since it's a bit long, here is the relevant bit:

Others thought that there was a ‘natural’ language, a primary tongue. Some suggested that it was Latin, others, out of religiosity, that it must be Hebrew, Greek or Aramaic. They went so far, under the patronage of bishops and monarchs who took an interest in the subject, as to take foundling children by way of experiment and isolate them completely from all human congress, to give them no access to language at all while they grew up, in the hope that they would revert to some posited universal and original language, the linguistic equivalent of a chemical element or primary tissue, and thereby prove once and for all which of the world’s tongues had primacy. Of course what happened was that such children invented their own language amongst themselves, true languages with wide vocabularies and complex syntactical structures. It is a shame in a way that it would now be considered too cruel to repeat the experiments, just imagine how much would be revealed by a study of these unique languages.

(I don't know how I got it into my head that the experimenters were Victorian, since he doesn't seem to say anything about that! ;) Anyway, it doesn't look as though he has any references where you can read more about it, but I found this section on Wikipedia, which says that the same experiment has been tried by some ancient pharaohs and kings:

[link]

Anyway, thanks again for your comment, I really appreciate it! :) :hug:
Reply
:iconspirit-of-the-rain:
Spirit-of-the-Rain Featured By Owner Jul 16, 2011  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Thank you for the quick reply... wow, huzzah for language experiments! I actually do wish that could be done again today... no offense to the children of course xD

And my message thing is from Doctor Who! The first episode in the sixth season (or the second season with Matt Smith in it).

Once again, no problem~
Reply
:iconthe-anonymous-c:
the-anonymous-c Featured By Owner May 7, 2011
I agree with so much of this! :hug: It's good that all us crazeh Snape fans understand each other on a level, at least! :giggle:

You know, this had me thinking, too. I actually love James and Harry as characters, but in a whole different way than I love Snape. And I love Snape on a whole different LEVEL than any of the other characters in the whole series. It's hard not to go on and on trying to explain this to other people who don't get it or :gasp: don't read HP at all. (I hate the 'it's a children's book, why do you like it so much' thing, too D: )
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner May 9, 2011
Thank you so much! :hug: It's awesome to know that there are other people out there who understand and share my obsession with Severus Snape! :heart: (Sorry about the late reply, by the way - I've been on holiday and only just got home. :faint: Am going to spend some time in the soothing world of DeviantArt before I start all the unpacking! ;))

I like Harry and James as characters too (not so keen on Sirius! ;)), but not on the same level as Severus, with all his cynicism and conflict! :love:
Reply
:iconthe-anonymous-c:
the-anonymous-c Featured By Owner May 9, 2011
I don't like Sirius either :rofl: Hmm ;) I understand he's been through a lot, but his character just kind of...bugged me? He and Draco were the only characters (aside from some of the obvious evil ones) that I just could not get into, AT ALL.

James or Harry would probably be my (DISTANT haha) second fave in the books, and from then on it gets sticky because I like a lot of characters! Luna is another fave. I like Lily okay, but mostly just in the context of Lily/James, which I adore.

Severus... is seriously on a level all his own :nod:. Hell, he gets his own TIER :love:. Every time I set out to explain why I love him I just want to say "EVERYTHING", because I get overwhelmed and don't know how or where to start (and honestly, 'everything' is a pretty good answer. People just blinked at me back when he wasn't so popular as now :lmao:). That's why I really appreciate essays like yours. You accomplish what I often cannot even organize myself on :glomp:
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner May 10, 2011
Thank you! :glomp: Since no-one else in my family understands my Snape-obsession, I've been rehearsing these arguments about why he is the most awesome character for YEARS! :giggle:

Sadly, I still haven't managed to convince them... :(

(Ah, well, it just means more Severus for us, I gues! ;))
Reply
:iconthe-anonymous-c:
the-anonymous-c Featured By Owner May 10, 2011
YEP :D :excited: Excellent way of looking at it ;)
Reply
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
:iconreader-one:
reader-one Featured By Owner Apr 29, 2010   Writer
I was thirteen when I started my Snape-obsession. I don't know WHY I like him, besides that he's just so amusing. I enjoy his sarcasm tremendously. He's nasty to Harry, yes, but I can understand that. Lily's eyes in James' face. It's like James had come back to haunt him and was saying "Hey, Snivellus! Lily's mine!" Or something along those lines. I generally despise the Maurauders (except Lupin and he had nothing to do with bullying Snape). Sirius Black is the worst though. "Hey, I'm bored! Let's go torture Snape!!" Disgusting.
Excellant writing by the way.
Another anti-hero who I also enjoy is Dustfinger from the Inkheart series.
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2010
:hug: Thank you so much, I'm really glad you liked the essay! (Sorry for the late response, I've been happily snowed-under with DeviantArt messages! :)) And I couldn't agree with you more about the marauders - Sirius Black is just evil, and we never see this god side of James that everyone is always talking about.

So you liked Severus from quite a young age? You have excellent taste! His sarcastic sense of humour is one of the things I love most about him too.
Reply
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
:iconreader-one:
reader-one Featured By Owner May 3, 2010   Writer
Thank you! And he is quite amusing. "Ghosts are transparent", of course they cut that from the movie. :shakefist:
Reply
:iconwearesevenstudios:
WeAreSevenStudios Featured By Owner Mar 23, 2010  Student
:worship: Fantastic! This is so well-written and researched. I love it! I found myself wanting to ask your permission to post it on my HP fansite, but then I realized I didn’t have an HP fansite (if I did, I would).

Hm. I'm really interested in your theory that those who love Snape first read the books as adults. I’d love to get some statistics on that. It’s true for me, in any case.

What you say about Snape’s intensity of emotions and his severity of emotional control is a really good point. Having grown up on Star Trek (I’m half-Trekkie on my dad’s side ;) ), I remember learning that the apparently emotionless Vulcans actually strove so hard for cold, unwavering logic because their natural emotions are so much more volatile and extreme than humans’. I think, with Snape, the practice is self-perpetuating as well. This stems only from my own beliefs about emotional processes, but I think that constant repression of feelings (like water behind a dam) creates an overflow more spectacular than free-reign. Of course, if Snape let it all hang out, he’d just be Sirius.

“Improbable, obsessive and masochistic” - yes, but those are the top three words (after greasy, hook-nosed, and sallow) that describe Snape. ;)

Here’s something you address that I argue about with certain friends. Some people I know who love Snape think he had this beautiful love that *is* the hero-love. The kind that every woman would want. I do not get that. At all. So I feel vindicated to read “It was very single-minded, sublimely self-controlled, unhealthy but beautiful love. It wasn't what every girl wanted – it wasn't even what the heroine wanted – but it was astonishing” - because I share that conclusion precisely. Obsessive, stalker-ly, one-sided, dangerous, uninformed, selfish, etc., but nonetheless beautiful, human, and as you put, astonishing.


I keep on meaning to write an essay comparing Snape to the classical, tragic hero. It’s probably been done dozens of times anyway. Still, you have re-inspired me to get on it.
Reply
Hidden by Owner
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Mar 23, 2010
:dance: Please write that essay comparing Snape to the tragic hero, I'd love to read it! :heart: If you do, you must sumbit it to our group: :iconspinners--end: as we only have one essay in our essays folder at the moment, and it's beginning to look a little lonely!

I love the comparison of Severus to the Vulcans, with their deep-seated emotions and consequent love of logic and self-control. And then, when Vulcans lose control, they really lose control! Isn't there an episode where Spock just goes crazy because he's trying to get back to Vulcan to his mate? That reminds me of Severus, with his sudden, scary explosions of emotion. :love:

Some people have replied to this essay, and said that they loved Severus even when they were reading the Harry Potter books as a child. I wonder if that means they never really identified with Harry. (I certainly never could - but then, I was reading the books as an adult, when I could see that Harry had good qualities even though I wanted to strangle him a lot of the time! ;)) Perhaps the people who loved Severus as a child just had very good taste for their age!

And, yes, I agree, I can't see Severus' love - or his actions - as the kind you'd get from a regular hero. I think there is a tendency among Snape fan-girls to see him either as a misunderstood hero or a scary, pitiless bad-ass, but he's always seemed to me to be somewhere in between!
Reply
:iconwearesevenstudios:
WeAreSevenStudios Featured By Owner Mar 23, 2010  Student
Thank you for your encouragement. :D
You wouldn't mind if I quoted (and credited - of course) a couple pieces of your essay in mine, would you?
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Mar 24, 2010
Of course I wouldn't mind - that would be great! :hug:
Reply
:iconvizen:
Vizen Featured By Owner Jan 31, 2010
You won't believe it - finally I read it. I saw it on jan 9th, I've been keeping it in a corner of my mind - and finally I read it. :faint:

Best Birthday gift ever, and also best opening for Spinners--End... What can I add to this ? of course, I agree with you and you know that, don't you ?

you know, you're so right - we should have some round of discussion about 'why does he appeal us like that?' . Also, I've been wondering for a while about it, and it's even more important now with Spiners--End : I wonder why it's so difficult to love Severus Snape in his entire canon identity. Or - another perspective on the same question - why are his representations so changing, altering his 'basic' book description ? when you see a Draco, a Ron, a Dumbledore fanart - they are almost all canon and recognizable. but Snape ! he's so different everywhere ! Even amongst the different most canon interpretations, he's different. Some want him handsome, romantic, the others powerful, or nasty, or funny. Of course, he is rich, multilayered, so there is no wonder... But there is under these multi-appearances a common ground, while all the masks or different faces can be really different. Severus is like that, himself - multiple and constant at the same time. And he shows what each of us want to see in him. :worship: - that's one another fascinating aspect of him - a part of his strange appeal on me :)


thank you again and bravo for this Lucy
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Feb 1, 2010
Yay! :boogie: Thank you so much for reading, Bea! I'm sorry it's taken me so long to respond - I wanted to wait until I had time to think about what you said and reply properly!

I agree - it seems so hard for people to accept the divergent parts of Sev's personality. He is either made into a misunderstood, romantic hero, or a callous man who doesn't care about Lily. I suppose he does have more contradictions than a lot of J.K. Rowling's characters, but I think the contradictions are logical. The fact that he can hate obsessively means that he can also love obsessively. There would be no life-long devotion to Lily without his life-long hatred of James Potter, and anyone who looks like him!

It is hard not to soften some of the aspects of Severus you don't like. I've made him much too articulate in my story - especially around Lily! I guess it's difficult to love someone without trying to reform them in little ways! ;)
Reply
:iconvizen:
Vizen Featured By Owner Feb 1, 2010
Indeed!
Reply
:iconjane-writer:
jane-writer Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2010
I'm interested in hearing your take on Snape's bullying of Harry and some of the other students - do you think it's excusable?

Oh, I was also wondering, would you mind if I used your article in my process journal for a writing course I'm doing? I'm doing a major work on anti-heroes (and of course I want Severus Snape to be my star).

I found this article eloquent...well, amazing. I will, of course, source it and give you credit. It wouldn't be used in my actual work, just my process journal. Thank you very much.
Reply
:iconls269:
ls269 Featured By Owner Jan 30, 2010
Of course that would be fine - I'm really flattered, thank you! That sounds like such an interesting project - I've always loved anti-heroes so much more than the supposed heroes, and I've always wondered what it is about them that appeals.

It's funny that you should mention Sev's bullying, because that's one of the things that makes me most uncomfortable about his character. The way he picks on Neville is so pointlessly cruel. (I never mnaged to feel that bad for Harry, I'm afraid! ;)) I don't think it's excusable, no, but these moments when you're almost revolted by him make him such an interesting character. (You should read Russell Brand's autobiography for that. So many times, reading that book, I thought: oh, my god, I can't believe you did that, but I still want to keep reading!) The bullying of Neville shows you how insecure Sev must have been, and what turmoil must have been going on in his mind, even before Voldemort came back. So, definitely not excusable, but very interesting, in a horrible kind of way! ;)

Thank you so much for your comments on this essay, I really appreciate it! :hug:
Reply
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
Hidden by Owner
(1 Reply)
Add a Comment:
 
×

:iconls269: More from ls269


Featured in Collections

Literature by cattail13


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
January 9, 2010
File Size
14.5 KB
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
2,412 (1 today)
Favourites
26 (who?)
Comments
90
×